• 0 Posts
  • 153 Comments
Joined 6 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 27th, 2024

help-circle
















  • you now admit that judges can determine a guilty or not guilty sentence

    As I’ve been repeating ad nauseum, that is not the role of the judge in a criminal trial with a jury present.

    a jury is meant to function outside of the established law by definition and instead focus on law as the people use and understand it

    This is patently false. A jury determines whether a defendant is guilty or not guilty. That’s it. There is no “we feel sad for the defendant” option. Read the transcript of any trial and see how the judge instructs the jury. Jurors do not make up the law “as the people understand it”.

    Chrystal, a girl who was sex trafficked most of her teens and is still young, wouldn’t know whether it’s better to go to trial or not.

    That’s why “Chrystul’s” legal team advised her on her position and instructed her to take the plea deal - because a jury would find her guilty. Obviously, if Jurors just made up the law based on the vibe of a case, her legal advisors would have told her to go to trial because the jury would undoubtedly sympathise with her and find her actions reasonable.

    They have jury nullification available literally specifically so juries can indeed nullify the law. That is part of the function of a jury. Just because that upsets you, doesn’t mean that’s not what they are for.

    It’s preposterous to assert that part of the function of a jury is to nullify the law. You have absolutely no evidence in support of that. If this were true in any way it would be a component in every criminal trial ever heard by a court. Why bother disputing evidence when you can simply talk about the sad circumstances of the defendant. “The victim deserved to be murdered because they were an asshole”.

    I suspect that you simply prefer to believe you live in a world where good will always triumph over evil. You might find this upsetting to acknowledge but any grown up understands that life just isn’t fair, and that bad things happen to good people.