Hey all, sorry if this was posted before, but lemmy search is hot dogshit at the moment, so I cannot really find anything relating to this topic.

Recently, I have been upgrading my email privacy bit by bit, and am in need of an email aliasing service / forwarding service. I have been looking online for a couple options and I’m currently down to 3 :

• Anonaddy
• Simplelogin
• Firefox Relay

Now, the main things I wish to know about each are, in your opinion, their pros and cons for a person with a pretty moderate-high threat model. Currently, these are the pros and cons that I have found :

• Anonaddy (Lite Plan)

  • Pros
    • Cheap at $1/m (billed yearly)
    • Can use Custom Domains (catchall, wildcard, etc)
    • Stores failed deliveries (could be important if my mailbox is full or something)
    • Open-source
  • Cons
    • Only 50 aliases using shared domains (custom subdomain are easily identifiable)
    • Owned by 1 or 2 guys, so not guaranteed to last as long as a company would per se. Doesn’t matter much if I use a custom domain.

• Simplelogin

  • Pros
    • Unlimited aliases using shared domains
    • Can use Custom Domains
    • Owned by Proton (this is a pro in the sense of a guarantee that it will last a good bit of time)
    • Open Source
  • Cons
    • Pricier at $2.5/m (billed yearly)
    • I do not use proton, so compatibility could be a downside.

• Firefox Relay

  • Pros
    • Cheap at $1/m (billed yearly)
    • Unlimited aliases using shared domain
    • Owned by Mozilla (more than likely will last longer than Proton)
  • Cons
    • They use Amazon SES/AWS, though they have contract to protect customer information
    • No Custom Domains

I am currently leaning towards either Relay or Anonaddy because of their 2.5x cheaper price (which does add up $12/y vs $30/y), but am very curious as to which you prefer and why. I will not be using these services for anything important (bank, govt, insurance, etc) as those go through a custom domain strictly for those. Junk, random accounts which aren’t important, newsletters, … will go through the aliasing service.

Thank you in advance, if something wasn’t clear let me know.