Looking for some games where it feels like you’re actually trying to solve something with the clues and secrets you uncover. For example, Disco Elysium actually made me feel like a detective despite how wacky and surreal it could be.
I haven’t played LA Noire yet but that’s on my list. Anything else I should check out? TIA!
You must log in or register to comment.
The Return of the Obra Dinn is by far the best detective game I have ever played.
If only the art style didn’t make my head hurt
To each their own, I love it though!
Oh yeah, I’m not saying it’s objectively bad. I have chronic migraines and trying to play it would make them worse, so it literally made my head hurt.
Oh, sorry to hear that. I can see how it would be migraine-inducing. But I’m glad that we all now agree that it’s objectively good :)
I really liked it. The music was iconic too, everything about the game is so unique. Sometimes I just listen to the OST and wish I could play the game for the first time again haha.
I’m familiar with that feeling lol
This game is in early access but is super promising so far. I’m in love with it!
This is what I came to recommend. I’m actually waiting for it to exit early access (or at least cook a bit longer), but it looks like a detective game wet dream.
I can’t get it out of my mind, only reason I haven’t bought it yet is because I don’t want to experience an inferior version of it.
Yeah I def get what you mean. I have a lot of games in early access on my wishlist that I want to wait for the EA period to end.
But for this one, with each case being different and randomly generated, I felt like I could experience it now without diminishing any experience I’d have when it has a full release
Shadows of Doubt is probably the closest thing to a pure detective game. It’s definitely a bit rough around the edges, but the core concept is really cool. I had a lot of fun playing it even in its current state, and look forward to coming back once it’s further along in development.
It’s really fun but still kinda rough around the edges. I wish there other games like this that are fully fleshed out and complete.
If you like puzzles while soving a mystery I would recommend any of The Room games or Agent A a puzzle in Disguise.
A lot of detective games are mostly point and click adventure games, which generally are older games or more indie style. That said there are a few I can think of:
The Gabriel Knight games have a lot of good detective elements, including some good puzzle solving. https://www.gog.com/en/game/gabriel_knight_sins_of_the_fathers
Chicken Police has a really neat interrogation mechanic and a fantastic noir setting. Its a bit silly all things considered, but the detective elements are fun. I’ve not beaten the game, but the time I’ve put into its fun. https://www.gog.com/en/game/chicken_police
In a similar vein, Backbone is a noir detective game set in an animal setting. The detective mechanics feel weaker, and the game seems to force you on to the critical path pretty hard, but its still been fun so far. https://www.gog.com/en/game/backbone
Finally, this is a horror game, but unraveling the mystery is fun and the game doesn’t railroad you on the critical path too hard. Simulacra is a game about a guy who receives a mysterious cell phone and he is using all the tools available on the phone to uncover the identity of the owner. Short and engrossing. https://www.gog.com/en/game/simulacra
Another one that I think is fun (though don’t get the sequel) is Don’t Feed the Monkies. This is more like Simulacra and is less detective game and more about experiencing the stories presented and unraveling a light mystery. Still fun and fits in the detective theme: https://www.gog.com/en/game/do_not_feed_the_monkeys
The Sexy Brutale is a really interesting game with more fantastical elements but there are some tricky puzzles to figure out with the clues the game gives you: https://www.gog.com/en/game/the_sexy_brutale
Last one, and one I’ve not played any of. Case of the Golden Idol apparently has multiple critical paths. Supposed to be really good. https://www.gog.com/en/game/the_case_of_the_golden_idol
Most of these are on sale now.
Chicken police was surprisingly well done.
I had some weird bugs replaying it recently but maybe you’ll have better luck than me - Orwell
Cloudpunk is more of a delivery game that has a mystery aspect but I enjoyed it (haven’t finished it yet)
CaseCracker was enjoyable but there were some translation issues I think so some things weren’t clear in English.
Not a detective game but would HIGHLY recommend Cloudpunk anyway. Amazing atmosphere, outstanding music, and the story made me cry so, ten out of ten.
Return of the Obra Dinn is a very good game about piecing together clues to find out who everybody is and their eventual fate.
Return of the Obra Dinn is worth checking out like others have mentioned. I also really enjoyed The Case of the Golden Idol, which is somewhat similar.
I’m surprised no one has mention The Outer Wilds yet. The whole game makes you feel like part detective, part archeologist, and one of the best games I’ve ever played.
All three of these are fantastic mystery stories. You have to pay some attention to what’s going on, nothing is explicitly spelled out (Golden Idol comes maybe the closest), but you feel SO smart when everything just clicks into place.
This might not fit what you’re looking for, but the Phoenix Wright games are mostly about detective work, despite playing as a lawyer. If you like wacky and surreal, the series should be right up your alley!
And if you like the Phoenix Wright games but don’t want to pay Phoenix Wright money, Avian Attorney is quite fun. And I’m now realizing I’m recommending a lot of animal based detective games.
I haven’t played either of these, but they sound very cool and have been on my wishlist for a while:
- Metaphobia - a FREE game on Steam. It’s a classic-style point-and-click adventure in the vein of Gabriel Knight.
- Shadows of Doubt - An immersive sandbox detective stealth game set in a fully simulated sci-fi noir city of crime and corruption. The world is procedurally generated and you can explore and take on cases freely. Discover, meet and tail individual citizens, each with their own name, job, apartment and daily routine, in unique, procedurally-generated cities. Each case has different culprits, clues and experiences for you to test your investigative skills.
You simply must play Technobabylon.
I wouldn’t rate L.A. Noire too highly, as it’s a weird hybrid between detective game and GTA.
What rubbed me the wrong way was the illusion of choice in side quests (roadside police work) where it seems like it’s always the worst possible outcome. The story, especially the choices my character made (without me having a say in it), wasn’t to my taste either.
deleted by creator
Think your comment showed up in the wrong thread gamer (Lemmy bug)
Whats weird is I am semi confident it was in the right thread at least at the beginning lol. Went back to it and saw my comment. Had that glitch happen to me too though while browsing.
Would Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney fit your bill? I mean it’s mostly about moon logical deduction but also finding clues and such.
It’s a different style, but Ghost Trick is being re released in HD very soon. I definitely recommend you give it a try!
An older game that fits this, which I loved and that ended up not really getting anymore content sadly, was D4: Dark Dreams Don’t Die. It’s worth a play though IMO.
It’s played in episodes and only ever got one “season” of content, so there’s a prologue and two episodes to play.
