• 0 Posts
  • 141 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 19th, 2024

help-circle






  • if morality were dictated to rational agents through an external source, we could not be sure of its objectivity (i.e., universal and necessary validity). Moreover, the notion of an external source that dictates morality conflicts with our being free moral agents. Hence we must legislate ourselves through our own faculty of reason such that the moral law holds objectively for rational agents such as us.

    I agree with everything here until the “must” of the last sentence, as it seems to be based on the implication that said free agents care. There are people who do not care for their own wellbeing, or the wellbeing of others. On a subjective basis, they lack the values that objective reasoning would be built on.

    To them that “must” is meaningless. Or worse, they view statements such as that as being dictated to them from an external source.

    On top of that, we aren’t completely rational, or able to make completely rational conclusions at all times. We can make attempts, sure. But we have biases, we fall into fallacies without realizing, and like I said some of us just don’t care.

    Morality can’t be objective if we can’t be objective.

    but I’d rather not recapitulate the entire work. If you’re interested, I would read the following entry page on the issue.

    I understand not wanting to do that, so all good.

    Though. I’m more interested in a discussion than anything else.














  • yeah im just saying one show does not mean anything.

    Nor have I said so. I was giving an example of how the boomers have valued cops, and how they view them.

    heck andy griffith was more a small town show than a cop show

    Sure, but the underlying effect and message of the show was “hey cops are the good guys, they’ll look out for your family”

    I would say cop vs general emergency responder vs hospital/doctor show ratios are not that different today than back when boomers were the main television audience

    That’s far better argument. Though I’d say it still misses the mark because even modern cop shows are still meant for an older group. Gen Z isn’t watching those shows. The closest is Brooklyn 99, which is closer to pornography than reality, or an attempt at reality. There’s also true crime, but often the value there is morbid curiosity, not “cops are good”.